Trip Bacon — The secret ingredient to the perfect getaway logo

Disney MagicvsIcon of the Seas

Side-by-side creator consensus from cruise reviewers across YouTube.

Disney Cruise Line logo
85% Bacon Score™
Disney Magic
🥓Powered by Trip Bacon
Add this Free Widget to your Blog
Royal Caribbean Group logo
71% Bacon Score™
Icon of the Seas
🥓Powered by Trip Bacon
Add this Free Widget to your Blog
Creators' Pick

The Bacon Verdict

Disney Magic wins this matchup

Earns a +14% higher BaconScore than Icon of the Seas. Based on 12687 creator reviews.

Lead+14%BaconScore

The Bacon Story

Data-driven recap

Across 12687 creator reviews, Disney Magic holds a +14% BaconScore lead over Icon of the Seas — 85% versus 71%. Disney Magic edges ahead on Value and safety medical, while Icon of the Seas leads on Wi-Fi. Coverage spans 1032 distinct cruise channels — read the full breakdown for each ship below.

Score comparison

Recommend
0%
of 6.3K reviews
6.3K videos478 channels1% warn againstDeveloping data
About our Bacon Score methodology

Opinion trend for Disney Magic

Holding steadyModerate consensus
Recommend
0%
of 6.4K reviews
6.4K videos554 channels3% warn againstDeveloping data
About our Bacon Score methodology

Opinion trend for Icon of the Seas

Holding steadyDivided opinion

Side-by-side facts

The specs

Disney Cruise Line logo
Disney Magic
Cruise line
Disney Cruise Line
Creator reviews
6307 videos
Distinct creators
478
Royal Caribbean Group logo
Icon of the Seas
Cruise line
Royal Caribbean Group
Creator reviews
6380 videos
Distinct creators
554

Topic Scoreboard

How they really compare

Disney Cruise Line logo

Disney Magic

Topic

Icon of the Seas

Royal Caribbean Group logo

Where creators agree

  • Disney Magic:
    474 mentions
    ShowsBoth like it
    Icon of the Seas:
    751 mentions
  • Disney Magic:
    81 mentions
    SuitesBoth like it
    Icon of the Seas:
    307 mentions
  • Disney Magic:
    49 mentions
    dining bars drinksBoth like it
    Icon of the Seas:
    350 mentions

Where creators diverge

  • Disney Magic:
    18 mentions
    Wi-Fi0.48 gap
    Icon of the Seas:
    80 mentions
  • Disney Magic:
    44 mentions
    Value0.46 gap
    Icon of the Seas:
    479 mentions
  • Disney Magic:
    59 mentions
    safety medical0.34 gap
    Icon of the Seas:
    249 mentions
How to read the Trip Bacon Score
Happy Bacon — creators loved this aspect
Sad Bacon — creators took issue with this
Meh — no strong opinion either way

Scale: 0–5 strips in half-step increments. 0 = “meh”, 5 = “bacon bliss”. Aggregated from creator-review sentiment, weighted by channel expertise.

About our Bacon Score methodology

Standout creator quotes

Positive · Disney Magic
“this is legitimately my dream it really is”
— Cruise With Ben and David · authority
Positive · Icon of the Seas
“The hospitality service that they give was 10 out of 10.”
— CHRIS WONG VLOGS · authority
Critical · Disney Magic
“this is our second place we got an Airbnb it was filthy just dirty everywhere”
— Cruise With Ben and David · authority
Critical · Icon of the Seas
“American Airlines shame on you”
— Sharon at Sea Travel · authority

Drill Deeper

See the full creator breakdown

Each detail page has the full creator panel, topic heatmap, monthly trends, audience breakdown, and verbatim quotes — far more than fits in this comparison.

Disney Cruise Line logo
Disney Cruise LineDisney Magic85% BaconScoreSee full ship breakdown
Royal Caribbean Group logo
Royal Caribbean GroupIcon of the Seas71% BaconScoreSee full ship breakdown

Other Disney Cruise Line ships

Disney Cruise Line logo
Disney Magic
🥓 85% Ship BaconScore™→

Disney Magic

Disney Cruise Line
11,249 videos
Disney Cruise Line logo
Disney Dream
🥓 86% Ship BaconScore™↑

Disney Dream

Disney Cruise Line
8,422 videos
Disney Cruise Line logo
Disney Wish
🥓 83% Ship BaconScore™↓

Disney Wish

Disney Cruise Line
7,460 videos
Disney Cruise Line logo
Disney Adventure
🥓 81% Ship BaconScore™→

Disney Adventure

Disney Cruise Line
4,184 videos
Disney Cruise Line logo
Disney Fantasy
🥓 84% Ship BaconScore™↓

Disney Fantasy

Disney Cruise Line
4,119 videos
Disney Cruise Line logo
Disney Treasure
🥓 82% Ship BaconScore™↓

Disney Treasure

Disney Cruise Line
3,833 videos

Other Royal Caribbean Group ships

Royal Caribbean Group logo
Icon of the Seas
🥓 71% Ship BaconScore™→

Icon of the Seas

Royal Caribbean Group
11,754 videos
Royal Caribbean Group logo
Wonder of the Seas
🥓 78% Ship BaconScore™↓

Wonder of the Seas

Royal Caribbean Group
9,759 videos
Royal Caribbean Group logo
Allure of the Seas
🥓 77% Ship BaconScore™↓

Allure of the Seas

Royal Caribbean Group
9,209 videos
Royal Caribbean Group logo
Harmony of the Seas
🥓 73% Ship BaconScore™→

Harmony of the Seas

Royal Caribbean Group
8,478 videos
Royal Caribbean Group logo
Adventure of the Seas
🥓 78% Ship BaconScore™↓

Adventure of the Seas

Royal Caribbean Group
8,320 videos
Royal Caribbean Group logo
Oasis of the Seas
🥓 75% Ship BaconScore™→

Oasis of the Seas

Royal Caribbean Group
8,223 videos

Watch creators on each ship

Disney Magic
The Disney Dream Ship Horn With Familiar Disney Melodies1:27

The Disney Dream Ship Horn With Familiar Disney Melodies

Disney Parks · 3.1M views · 15 years ago
Bret Iwan: Drawn To Mickey | Disney Files On Demand3:48Tour

Bret Iwan: Drawn To Mickey | Disney Files On Demand

Disney Parks · 2.3M views · 3 years ago
Highly Positive
Icon of the Seas
Mumbai to Goa Cruise | Cordelia Cruises Empress29:59

Mumbai to Goa Cruise | Cordelia Cruises Empress

200Journeys · 5.2M views · 4 years ago
Mumbai to Goa Cruise | Jalesh Cruise Karnika33:19

Mumbai to Goa Cruise | Jalesh Cruise Karnika

200Journeys · 4.5M views · 6 years ago

More matchups

Compare with…

How this comparison is built

Scores aggregate every cruise creator review we've indexed for each entity, weighted by creator expertise and capped per channel so no single voice dominates. Read the full methodology →